====== Methane, from electrochemical methanation, with carbon from atmospheric CO2 capture — CH ====== //Dataset documentation and final control (tdc-doc, imported mode)// \\ [[bafuq>activity:methane_from_electrochemical_methanation_with_carbon_from_atmospheric_co2_capture__ch|Open this dataset in OpenData]] > **Abstract.** BAFU 2026 v1 (Swiss Federal Office for the Environment). Dataset Methane, from electrochemical methanation, with carbon from atmospheric CO2 capture [CH], per 1 kg. EF v3.1 climate change 4.403 kg CO2 eq (Monte Carlo 95 % interval 3.393–6.956). Main contributors: Hydrogen production, gaseous, 30 bar, from PEM electrolysis,… 63 %; Carbon dioxide, captured from atmosphere, with a sorbent-bas… 37 %. Status: final control passed. ^ Item ^ Value ^ | Dataset name | Methane, from electrochemical methanation, with carbon from atmospheric CO2 capture | | Dataset UUID / graph id | ''%%a202e20e-4d22-3e9a-96fd-83d98eca2736%%'' / ''%%activity:methane_from_electrochemical_methanation_with_carbon_from_atmospheric_co2_capture__ch%%'' | | Reference product, unit | Methane, from electrochemical methanation, with carbon from atmospheric CO2 capture, 1 kg | | Location | CH | | Time period | 2024-01/2024-01 | | Category | fuels / synthetic\transformation | | Source database | BAFU 2026 v1 (Swiss Federal Office for the Environment), version 2026 v1 | | Publisher | Swiss Federal Office for the Environment (FOEN/BAFU) | | Background database | BAFU 2026 v1 (graph ''%%bafuquery-db%%'') | | LCIA method | EF v3.1, consensus-flow-list implementation, 25 categories (bw2calc on the graph matrix) | | Status | final control passed | | Documented by | tdc-doc, imported mode (graph recalculation, Monte Carlo, final control), 2026-11-17 | ===== Introduction ===== Originally in cubic meter. Composition: 96% CH4, 4% CO2, Density of synthetic methane: 0.72 kg/Nm3, LHV ~47.5 MJ/kg. Using the "CO2 methanation - sewage sludge - PSA - worst - BFB_FB" configuration. Source: Life cycle assessment of power-to-gas with biogas as the carbon source. Xiaojin Zhang, Julia Witte, Tilman Schildhauer and Christian Bauer. https://doi.org/10.1/C9SE00986H Source: Life cycle assessment of power-to-gas with biogas as the carbon source. Xiaojin Zhang, Julia Witte, Tilman Schildhauer and Christian Bauer. https://doi.org/10.1039/C9SE00986H UUID: a202e20e-4d22-3e9a-96fd-83d98eca2736 This report documents an **imported** dataset: its inventory and metadata come from the publisher, not from the tdc pipeline. tdc-doc recomputes it on the graph, checks it (Section 7), and reports it in the ISO 14044 / BAFU DQR v2.1 structure used for tdc's own datasets. Sections that only apply to datasets built by tdc (stoichiometry, energy model, literature excerpts) are replaced by what the publisher declares. ===== Goal and scope ===== ==== Function, functional unit and reference flow ==== Reference flow: **1 kg** of Methane, from electrochemical methanation, with carbon from atmospheric CO2 capture (CH). All results are given per unit of the reference flow. ==== System boundary ==== — ==== Technology ==== — ==== Link to the background database ==== Native BAFU dataset: exchanges as delivered in EcoSpold v1, linked by the graph migration (graphlca.load). ==== LCIA method ==== EF v3.1, characterisation only (no normalisation or weighting), consensus-flow-list implementation of the 25 categories, with regionalised factors where the flow carries a place. ===== Life cycle inventory ===== ==== Inventory table ==== Direct exchanges per reference flow, ordered by their share of climate change. //Uncertainty//: the distribution declared on the graph edge (BAFU: lognormal from the pedigree matrix). //Pedigree//: the scores the publisher declares (BAFU: reliability, completeness, temporal, geographical, technological, sample size; PEF DQR otherwise). ^ Exchange ^ Type ^ Location / compartment ^ Amount ^ Unit ^ Uncertainty ^ Pedigree ^ GWP share (%) ^ ^ Notes ^ | Hydrogen production, gaseous, 30 bar, from PEM electrolysis, from grid electrici… | technosphere | CH | 0.4982 | kg | lognormal, GSD² 1.38 | — | 62.7 | █████████████ | | | Carbon dioxide, captured from atmosphere, with a sorbent-based direct air captur… | technosphere | CH | 2.75 | kg | lognormal, GSD² 1.38 | — | 37.0 | ███████ | | | Sabatier reaction methanation unit construction | technosphere | RER | 3.9470e-07 | p | lognormal, GSD² 3.14 | — | 0.3 | · | | | Production of nickel-based catalyst for methanation | technosphere | RER | 8.3680e-05 | kg | lognormal, GSD² 1.38 | — | 0.0 | · | | | Transport, freight, lorry, 16t-32t gross weight, fleet average | technosphere | CH | 4.1840e-06 | tkm | lognormal, GSD² 2.21 | — | 0.0 | · | | | Transport, freight, rail, electricity with shunting | technosphere | CH | 5.0210e-05 | tkm | lognormal, GSD² 2.21 | — | 0.0 | · | | ==== Data quality ==== 0 of 6 direct exchanges carry a declared pedigree, 6 carry a distribution. ^ Field ^ As declared by the publisher ^ | Data generator / entry / validation | data generator: Romain Sacchi (PSI); data entry: Romain Sacchi (PSI); validation (proof reading): Romain Sacchi (PSI) | | sampling procedure | Sampling procedure: Literature data | | validation details | Proof reading validation: Passed, Other validation: none, Validator: Rolf Frischknecht, Telephone: 0041 44 940 61 91, E-mail: frischknecht@treeze.ch, Company: treeze, Country: CH | ==== Data gaps, proxies and assumptions ==== None recorded. ===== Life cycle impact assessment (EF v3.1) ===== Per 1 kg. The 95 % interval and GSD² come from the Monte Carlo of Section 6.4. ^ Impact category ^ Indicator ^ Unit ^ Result ^ 2.5 % ^ 97.5 % ^ GSD² ^ | Acidification | Accumulated Exceedance (AE) | mol H+ eq | **0.01153** | 0.008756 | 0.02255 | 1.61 | | Climate change-Biogenic | Radiative forcing as Global Warming Potential (GWP100) | kg CO2 eq | **0.07579** | 0.04775 | 0.1448 | 1.75 | | Climate change-Fossil | Radiative forcing as Global Warming Potential (GWP100) | kg CO2 eq | **4.318** | 3.322 | 6.846 | 1.44 | | Climate change-Land use and land use change | Radiative forcing as Global Warming Potential (GWP100) | kg CO2 eq | **0.009092** | 0.005504 | 0.01649 | 1.74 | | Climate change | Radiative forcing as Global Warming Potential (GWP100) | kg CO2 eq | **4.403** | 3.393 | 6.956 | 1.44 | | EF-particulate Matter | Impact on human health | disease incidence | **1.726e-07** | 1.300e-07 | 3.443e-07 | 1.65 | | Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics | Comparative Toxic Unit for ecosystems (CTUe) | CTUe | **14.5** | 11.23 | 35.26 | 1.81 | | Ecotoxicity, freshwater_organics | Comparative Toxic Unit for ecosystems (CTUe) | CTUe | **0.2502** | 0.192 | 0.6759 | 1.92 | | Ecotoxicity, freshwater | Comparative Toxic Unit for ecosystems (CTUe) | CTUe | **14.76** | 11.47 | 35.72 | 1.81 | | Eutrophication marine | Fraction of nutrients reaching marine end compartment (N) | kg N eq | **0.002894** | 0.002285 | 0.005021 | 1.51 | | Eutrophication, freshwater | Fraction of nutrients reaching freshwater end compartment (P) | kg P eq | **0.002864** | 0.001459 | 0.01265 | 2.93 | | Eutrophication, terrestrial | Accumulated Exceedance (AE) | mol N eq | **0.02139** | 0.01732 | 0.03811 | 1.49 | | Human toxicity, cancer_inorganics | Comparative Toxic Unit for human (CTUh) | CTUh | **8.024e-10** | 7.087e-10 | 2.554e-09 | 1.94 | | Human toxicity, cancer_organics | Comparative Toxic Unit for human (CTUh) | CTUh | **1.399e-09** | 9.702e-10 | 2.714e-09 | 1.67 | | Human toxicity, cancer | Comparative Toxic Unit for human (CTUh) | CTUh | **2.201e-09** | 1.802e-09 | 4.838e-09 | 1.66 | | Human toxicity, non-cancer_inorganics | Comparative Toxic Unit for human (CTUh) | CTUh | **5.029e-08** | 4.003e-08 | 1.787e-07 | 2.19 | | Human toxicity, non-cancer_organics | Comparative Toxic Unit for human (CTUh) | CTUh | **3.489e-09** | 2.074e-09 | 1.056e-08 | 2.24 | | Human toxicity, non-cancer | Comparative Toxic Unit for human (CTUh) | CTUh | **5.378e-08** | 4.284e-08 | 1.866e-07 | 2.17 | | Ionising radiation, human health | Human exposure efficiency relative to U235 | kBq U235 eq | **20.43** | 7.031 | 114.5 | 4.36 | | Land use | Soil quality index | pt (soil quality index) | **44.8** | 27.02 | 89.3 | 1.85 | | Ozone depletion | Ozone Depletion Potential (ODP) | kg CFC-11 eq | **3.901e-07** | 2.703e-07 | 6.794e-07 | 1.6 | | Photochemical ozone formation - human health | Tropospheric ozone concentration increase | kg NMVOC eq | **0.008635** | 0.006972 | 0.01675 | 1.57 | | Resource use, fossils | Abiotic resource depletion fossil fuels (ADP-fossil) | MJ | **226.4** | 155.8 | 381.8 | 1.58 | | Resource use, minerals and metals | Abiotic resource depletion (ADP ultimate reserve) | kg Sb eq | **3.241e-05** | 1.631e-05 | 9.855e-05 | 2.47 | | Water use | User deprivation potential (deprivation-weighted water consumption) | m3 world eq deprived | **1.976** | -7139 | 3257 | — | Climate change 4.403 kg CO2 eq per kg. Main contributors: Hydrogen production, gaseous, 30 bar, from PEM electrolysis,… 63 %; Carbon dioxide, captured from atmosphere, with a sorbent-bas… 37 %. ===== Interpretation ===== ==== Significant issues ==== Direct exchanges dominating climate change: Hydrogen production, gaseous, 30 bar, from PEM electrolysis,… 63 %; Carbon dioxide, captured from atmosphere, with a sorbent-bas… 37 %. Most sensitive exchanges (Section 6.3): Hydrogen production, gaseous, 30 bar, from PEM electrolysis, from grid electricity [CH] (-17.1 / +23.5 %); Carbon dioxide, captured from atmosphere, with a sorbent-based direct air capture system, … (-10.1 / +13.9 %); Sabatier reaction methanation unit construction [RER] (-0.2 / +0.5 %). ==== Independent recalculation ==== Graph result against BAFU 2026 v1 published EF 3.1 results (LCIA Results.xlsx, June 2026): ^ Category ^ Graph ^ Published ^ Graph / published ^ | Acidification | 0.01153 | 0.01282 | 0.899 | | Climate change-Biogenic | 0.07579 | 0.07579 | 1.000 | | Climate change-Fossil | 4.318 | 4.318 | 1.000 | | Climate change-Land use and land use change | 0.009092 | 0.009092 | 1.000 | | Climate change | 4.403 | 4.403 | 1.000 | | EF-particulate Matter | 1.726e-07 | 1.726e-07 | 1.000 | | Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics | 14.5 | 15.15 | 0.957 | | Ecotoxicity, freshwater_organics | 0.2502 | 0.2467 | 1.014 | | Ecotoxicity, freshwater | 14.76 | 15.39 | 0.958 | | Eutrophication marine | 0.002894 | 0.002885 | 1.003 | | Eutrophication, freshwater | 0.002864 | 0.002864 | 1.000 | | Eutrophication, terrestrial | 0.02139 | 0.02369 | 0.903 | | Human toxicity, cancer_inorganics | 8.024e-10 | 7.651e-10 | 1.049 | | Human toxicity, cancer_organics | 1.399e-09 | 1.399e-09 | 1.000 | | Human toxicity, cancer | 2.201e-09 | 2.164e-09 | 1.017 | | Human toxicity, non-cancer_inorganics | 5.029e-08 | 4.843e-08 | 1.038 | | Human toxicity, non-cancer_organics | 3.489e-09 | 3.489e-09 | 1.000 | | Human toxicity, non-cancer | 5.378e-08 | 5.192e-08 | 1.036 | | Ionising radiation, human health | 20.43 | 20.43 | 1.000 | | Land use | 44.8 | 36.43 | 1.230 | | Ozone depletion | 3.901e-07 | 3.901e-07 | 1.000 | | Photochemical ozone formation - human health | 0.008635 | 0.008635 | 1.000 | | Resource use, fossils | 226.4 | 226.4 | 1.000 | | Resource use, minerals and metals | 3.241e-05 | 3.187e-05 | 1.017 | | Water use | 1.976 | 2.173 | 0.909 | | Over all BAFU datasets, climate change agrees with the published table for 98.1 % of them within ±5 % (median ×1.000). Systematic differences are expected where the graph characterises differently from BAFU's table: regionalised factors (acidification, terrestrial eutrophication, land use, water use, by the flow's place) and the metal resource factors; these categories: Acidification median ×0.81 (16 % within ±5 %); Eutrophication, terrestrial median ×0.93 (37 % within ±5 %); Land use median ×1.23 (6 % within ±5 %); Resource use, minerals and metals median ×1.04 (52 % within ±5 %); Water use median ×0.75 (11 % within ±5 %). BAFU's table is per its own unit (electricity per MJ, cars per m, crops per m2), converted here, and carries the organics and inorganics sub-indicators of freshwater ecotoxicity in each other's column (primary copper: 99.7 % of its ecotoxicity under 'organics'); they are compared like with like. | | | | | Also published by BAFU for this dataset: IPCC 2021 GWP100 4.401 kg CO2 eq; Ecological Scarcity | | | | | 2021 total 1.571e+04 UBP. | | | | ==== Sensitivity check ==== One at a time on each direct exchange, over its declared 95 % range (±50 % when none is declared, the tdc-doc default for an assumption without a range). The supply chain behind each input is held at its mean. ^ Exchange ^ Base ^ Low / high ^ Range ^ Δ GWP100 (%) ^ Δ other categories (max %) ^ | Hydrogen production, gaseous, 30 bar, from PEM electrolysis, from grid electricity [CH] | 0.4982 kg | ×0.727 / ×1.38 | lognormal, GSD² 1.38 | -17.1 / +23.5 | 35.6 (Ionising radiation, human health) | | Carbon dioxide, captured from atmosphere, with a sorbent-based direct air capture system, … | 2.75 kg | ×0.727 / ×1.38 | lognormal, GSD² 1.38 | -10.1 / +13.9 | 17.9 (Ecotoxicity, freshwater_organics) | | Sabatier reaction methanation unit construction [RER] | 3.947e-07 p | ×0.326 / ×3.07 | lognormal, GSD² 3.14 | -0.2 / +0.5 | 3.4 (Human toxicity, cancer_inorganics) | | Production of nickel-based catalyst for methanation [RER] | 8.368e-05 kg | ×0.727 / ×1.38 | lognormal, GSD² 1.38 | -0.0 / +0.0 | 0.1 (Acidification) | | Transport, freight, lorry, 16t-32t gross weight, fleet average [CH] | 4.184e-06 tkm | ×0.46 / ×2.17 | lognormal, GSD² 2.21 | -0.0 / +0.0 | 0.0 (Ecotoxicity, freshwater_organics) | | Transport, freight, rail, electricity with shunting [CH] | 5.021e-05 tkm | ×0.46 / ×2.17 | lognormal, GSD² 2.21 | -0.0 / +0.0 | 0.0 (Land use) | ==== Uncertainty analysis ==== Monte Carlo over the whole supply chain: 1000 draws (seed 42, computed 2026-11-17), every exchange of the database that carries a distribution resampled at each draw, one adjoint solve per category per draw. Exchanges without a distribution enter as fixed values (Section 4.3). Results in Section 5. ==== Comparison with other data ==== No other location of this dataset in the graph. ==== Conclusions and limitations ==== GWP100 4.403 kg CO2 eq per kg (95 % interval 3.393–6.956). Dominant contributors: Hydrogen production, gaseous, 30 bar, from PEM electrolysis,… 63 %; Carbon dioxide, captured from atmosphere, with a sorbent-bas… 37 %. Most sensitive: Hydrogen production, gaseous, 30 bar, from PEM electrolysis, from grid electricity [CH] (-17.1 / +23.5 %); Carbon dioxide, captured from atmosphere, with a sorbent-based direct air capture system, … (-10.1 / +13.9 %); Sabatier reaction methanation unit construction [RER] (-0.2 / +0.5 %). final control passed. The documentation relies on the publisher's metadata; this report is not a critical review in the sense of ISO 14044 clause 6. ===== Final control ===== ^ Item ^ Status ^ Detail ^ | reference flow | **PASS** | production amount 1.0 kg | | closure: sum of direct contributions = dataset score (all 25 categories) | **PASS** | largest relative gap 3.8e-16 | | independent recalculation vs BAFU 2026 v1 published EF 3.1 results (LCIA Results.xlsx, June 2026) (climate change) | **PASS** | graph / published = 1; categories within ±5 %: 21/25 | | every technosphere input of the EcoSpold delivery is in the graph | **PASS** | all present (bafu_links_check.py) | | uncertainty declared on the direct exchanges | **PASS** | 6/6 exchanges carry a distribution (100 %); the others enter the Monte Carlo as fixed values | | Monte Carlo 95 % interval contains the deterministic score | **PASS** | 4.403 in [3.393, 6.956] | | time period declared | **PASS** | 2024-01/2024-01 | | geography is a known location code | **PASS** | CH | | sources cited | **PASS** | 2 reference(s), of which 1 dataset source(s); 0 resolved to a bibliographic record (DOI or Crossref/OpenAlex match), the others kept as the publisher declares them | ===== References ===== - Report — //source; as declared by BAFU (not found in OpenAlex/Crossref)// - Life Cycle Inventory database of the Swiss Federal Administration, BAFU:2026 — //database; dataset citation// - International Organization for Standardization (2006). ISO 14044:2006 Environmental management — Life cycle assessment — Requirements and guidelines (incl. Amd 1:2017, Amd 2:2020). Geneva. - Frischknecht R. (2023). FOEN LCI data — Data quality requirements (DQR) v2.1. treeze Ltd. on behalf of the Swiss Federal Office for the Environment (FOEN/BAFU), Uster / Bern. //(tdc-doc method reference; title, version and year to verify against the user's copy)// - European Commission, Joint Research Centre (2022). Environmental Footprint (EF) reference package 3.1. Ispra. - Mutel C. (2017). Brightway: An open source framework for Life Cycle Assessment. Journal of Open Source Software 2(12), 236. https://doi.org/10.21105/joss.00236 ===== Annex — licence and terms of use ===== BAFU:2026 Terms of Use - free use, processing and reuse of the data (including in LCA studies and calculators); the data may not be sold, resold or distributed as a database; modifications must be documented and shared under equivalent terms; credit required. ---- To suggest a correction or a dataset that does not exist yet, use [[proposals:start|Propose a dataset]].