datasets:tdc:41de602b-4297-5a5d-984d-d6612bebbce4
Differences
This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.
| Next revision | Previous revision | ||
| datasets:tdc:41de602b-4297-5a5d-984d-d6612bebbce4 [2026/11/16 12:02] – created - external edit 127.0.0.1 | datasets:tdc:41de602b-4297-5a5d-984d-d6612bebbce4 [2026/11/20 00:27] (current) – removed - external edit (Unknown date) 127.0.0.1 | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| - | ====== Life Cycle Inventory of Carbon fiber, PAN-based, high modulus (HM), wet spinning — Asia (RAS) ====== | ||
| - | |||
| - | // | ||
| - | |||
| - | ^ Item ^ Value ^ | ||
| - | | Dataset name (BAFU naming rules, DQR §4.7.1) | PAN-based carbon fiber, high modulus HM, wet spinning, from regional PAN precursor fiber, 1 kg | | ||
| - | | Dataset UUID / version | pan-based-carbon-fiber-high-modulus-hm-wet-spinning-from-regional-pan-precursor-fiber-1-kg-208c39 / draft (tdc) | | ||
| - | | Reference product, unit | Carbon fiber, PAN-based, high modulus (HM), wet spinning, kg | | ||
| - | | Location (DQR location code) | RAS — Asia | | ||
| - | | Reference year / time period | 2025 / 2025 | | ||
| - | | Technology level | current average technology (as described in the sources, Section 3) | | ||
| - | | Background database | BAFU 2026 v1 (Memgraph graph '' | ||
| - | | LCIA method | EF v3.1 (European Commission, Joint Research Centre 2022) (Brightway 2 / bw2calc (Mutel 2017)) | | ||
| - | | Status | ready for external review | | ||
| - | | Prepared by | tdc pipeline (datasetcreator agent), documentation and final check by tdc-doc | | ||
| - | |||
| - | ===== 1 Introduction ===== | ||
| - | |||
| - | Oxidation carbonisation graphitisation sizing of wet-spun PAN precursor into HM carbon fiber. Region RAS. FU 1 kg. | ||
| - | |||
| - | This report documents the dataset according to ISO 14040 (//ISO 14040:2006 Environmental Management — Life Cycle Assessment — Principles and Framework (Incl. Amd 1:2020)// 2006) and ISO 14044 (//ISO 14044:2006 Environmental Management — Life Cycle Assessment — Requirements and Guidelines (Incl. Amd 1:2017, Amd 2:2020)// 2006) and to the BAFU LCI Data Quality Requirements v2.1 (Frischknecht 2023). It is written for the external critical reviewer (ISO 14044 clause 6, ISO/TS 14071 (//ISO/TS 14071:2014 Environmental Management — Life Cycle Assessment — Critical Review Processes and Reviewer Competencies// | ||
| - | |||
| - | ===== 2 Goal and scope definition (ISO 14044, 4.2) ===== | ||
| - | |||
| - | ==== 2.1 Goal of the study ==== | ||
| - | |||
| - | * Intended application: | ||
| - | * Reasons for carrying out the study: missing dataset in the background database | ||
| - | * Intended audience: LCA practitioners, | ||
| - | * Comparative assertions intended to be disclosed to the public: no | ||
| - | |||
| - | ==== 2.2 Functional unit and reference flow ==== | ||
| - | |||
| - | The functional unit is 1 kg of product at the plant gate. Reference flow: **1 kg** of Carbon fiber, PAN-based, high modulus (HM), wet spinning at the plant gate. Product definition: Sized HM carbon fiber, 12K tow, tensile modulus 377 GPa, tensile strength 4400 MPa, C > 99%, sizing 50B 1.0%. Reference: TORAYCA M40J data sheet. [see product exchange]. | ||
| - | |||
| - | ==== 2.3 Product system and system boundary ==== | ||
| - | |||
| - | Cradle-to-gate: | ||
| - | |||
| - | {{ : | ||
| - | |||
| - | //Product system and system boundary (unit processes, flows crossing the boundary).// | ||
| - | |||
| - | ^ Life cycle stage ^ Included ^ Notes / source ^ | ||
| - | | Fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | | Exhaust gas treatment 1 | yes | 37.02 kg per kg product | | ||
| - | | Exhaust gas treatment 2 (regenerative thermal oxidizer) | yes | 10.83 kg per kg product | | ||
| - | | Fiber drying and sizing | yes | 1.021 kg per kg product | | ||
| - | | Graphitisation (high-modulus grade, no benchmark counterpart) | yes | 1 kg per kg product | | ||
| - | |||
| - | ==== 2.4 Cut-off criteria ==== | ||
| - | |||
| - | No intentional cut-off; missing items are listed as data gaps. Flows excluded by cut-off are listed with their estimated mass/energy share in Section 4.6. | ||
| - | |||
| - | ==== 2.5 Allocation procedures ==== | ||
| - | |||
| - | No co-product allocation (single reference product). | ||
| - | |||
| - | ==== 2.6 LCIA method and impact categories ==== | ||
| - | |||
| - | EF v3.1 (European Commission, Joint Research Centre 2022), all impact categories, characterisation only. Normalisation and weighting are not applied (optional elements, ISO 14044 4.4.3); no weighting is used for any comparison. | ||
| - | |||
| - | ==== 2.7 Data requirements and data quality requirements (ISO 14044 4.2.3.6) ==== | ||
| - | |||
| - | ^ Requirement ^ Target ^ Achieved (see Section 4.5) ^ | ||
| - | | Time-related coverage | 2020–2026 data | 2025 | | ||
| - | | Geographical coverage | Asia | 12 geographical proxy dataset(s): Chemical plant, organics: ‘Chemical plant, organics’ used at RER (no RAS version) — geographical pro; Water, process, for surface treatment and sizing: ‘Water, deionised, at plant’ used at CH (no RAS ve; Transport, freight, rail: ‘Transport, | ||
| - | | Technology coverage | current industrial technology | Section 3 | | ||
| - | | Precision | lognormal uncertainty and pedigree on every flow (Frischknecht 2023) | lognormal on every exchange; Monte Carlo GWP100 95 % interval 71.4–87.4 | | ||
| - | | Completeness | all inventory classes (raw materials, catalyst, neutralisation, | ||
| - | | Representativeness | market-weighted route and feedstock | Section 3 (market and routes) | | ||
| - | | Consistency | one modelling approach for all regions/ | ||
| - | | Reproducibility | every value computed by a tool or cited | all amounts reproduced by tdc-doc | | ||
| - | | Sources of data | ≥ 3 peer-reviewed articles (Crossref-verified), | ||
| - | | Uncertainty of information | Monte Carlo on the pedigree distributions | Section 6.5 | | ||
| - | |||
| - | ==== 2.8 Assumptions and limitations ==== | ||
| - | |||
| - | * none recorded | ||
| - | |||
| - | ==== 2.9 Type of critical review ==== | ||
| - | |||
| - | External critical review by an independent expert (ISO/TS 14071) — pending. | ||
| - | |||
| - | ===== 3 Product, market and technology ===== | ||
| - | |||
| - | ==== 3.1 Product definition and grades ==== | ||
| - | |||
| - | Sized HM carbon fiber, 12K tow, tensile modulus 377 GPa, tensile strength 4400 MPa, C > 99%, sizing 50B 1.0%. Reference: TORAYCA M40J data sheet. | ||
| - | |||
| - | ==== 3.2 Market, production volumes and production routes ==== | ||
| - | |||
| - | Region: RAS (Asia). Everything process-identical to cf-v2-hm-rer (same route, same chemistry, same per-kg stoichiometry and energy); only region-dependent items differ (electricity/ | ||
| - | |||
| - | == 3.2.0.1 1. Production routes and shares == | ||
| - | |||
| - | Carbon fiber is produced almost exclusively from polyacrylonitrile (PAN) precursor fiber. More than 90% of today’s high-performance carbon fibers are PAN-based ([[https:// | ||
| - | |||
| - | The transformation from precursor to finished fiber has three heat stages: 1. oxidative stabilization in air at 200-300 C for 1-2 h (prenzel_2023_carbon_fiber_lca, | ||
| - | |||
| - | == 3.2.0.2 2. Raw materials and origins == | ||
| - | |||
| - | * PAN precursor fiber (wet-spun): the dominant feedstock; in the global LCA model of (prenzel_2023_carbon_fiber_lca) PAN production is assumed in Japan because “Asia-Pacific region is the most relevant provider of all produced PAN worldwide (forecast 2023: 63% of global production)” (sec. 4). | ||
| - | * Nitrogen (inert gas for carbonization): | ||
| - | * Air / oxygen for the stabilization furnace. | ||
| - | * Sizing agent (epoxy/ | ||
| - | * Electrolyte for electrochemical surface treatment (prenzel_2023_carbon_fiber_lca, | ||
| - | |||
| - | == 3.2.0.3 3. Production volumes (world and regional) == | ||
| - | |||
| - | * **World**: global average carbon fiber demand volume ~**126,500 t in 2024** ([[https:// | ||
| - | * **China**: annual production capacity reached **135,500 t by end-2024** ([[https:// | ||
| - | * **Asia-Pacific** ~63% of global PAN production (forecast 2023, cited in prenzel_2023_carbon_fiber_lca, | ||
| - | * **Asia (RAS)**: dominant producing region — China (capacity 135,500 t end-2024, hongbangfrp.com) plus Japan (Toray M40J manufactured in “Japan and France”, toray_m40j_data_sheet; | ||
| - | * Main producing regions for CF: Asia (China, Japan), North America (USA: Toray/ | ||
| - | |||
| - | == 3.2.0.4 4. Grade context (HM vs HT) == | ||
| - | |||
| - | Most produced carbon fibers are standard (high-tenacity, | ||
| - | |||
| - | == 3.2.0.5 5. Modelling decision (RAS) == | ||
| - | |||
| - | * Route: PAN wet-spun precursor -> stabilization -> carbonization (low-T + high-T/ | ||
| - | * Region: RAS (Asia). Electricity and heat inputs are bound to the Asian BAFU grid/heat sets (“Electricity, | ||
| - | * Precursor: '' | ||
| - | * Alternative route (pitch-based CF) NOT modelled: <10% of the market and not the product requested. | ||
| - | |||
| - | ^ Item ^ Value ^ Year ^ Source ^ | ||
| - | |||
| - | ==== 3.3 Process description ==== | ||
| - | |||
| - | Oxidation carbonisation graphitisation sizing of wet-spun PAN precursor into HM carbon fiber. Region RAS. FU 1 kg. Processing steps as recorded in the unit process: | ||
| - | |||
| - | ^ Step ^ Conditions (T, p, time) ^ Main inputs/ | ||
| - | | Feed and unwinding of PAN precursor fiber | The wet-spun PAN precursor fiber (tow) is fed from the regional precursor spools onto the fiber oven system; continuous fiber feeding at controlled tension and speed. | | [] | | ||
| - | | Oxidation / stabilization | The precursor fiber is heated in air at 250-300 C to stabilize and ladder the polyacrylonitrile structure; exothermic conversion that removes volatile nitrogen- and hydrogen-bearing species (HCN, NH3, H2O). | | [] | | ||
| - | | Low-temperature carbonization | The stabilized fiber is heated under an inert atmosphere (nitrogen) at 400-600 C; remaining hydrogen, nitrogen and oxygen are released as CO, CO2, HCN, NH3, H2O, CH4 and N2, converting the fiber into a carbon-rich structure. | | [] | | ||
| - | | High-temperature carbonization / graphitisation | For the high-modulus grade the fiber is heated under inert gas at elevated temperature (up to ~2500 C) under high longitudinal draw tension to grow and align the graphitic crystallites, | ||
| - | | Surface treatment and sizing | The carbon fiber surface is treated (chemical/ | ||
| - | | Winding and packaging | The sized carbon fiber is wound onto spools and packaged; fiber dust and soot are collected and handled as solid waste. | | [] | | ||
| - | | Exhaust gas treatment | The oven and graphitisation exhaust gases are treated (oxidation/ | ||
| - | |||
| - | ===== 4 Life cycle inventory analysis (ISO 14044, 4.3) ===== | ||
| - | |||
| - | ==== 4.1 Data collection ==== | ||
| - | |||
| - | Two-step literature search: (1) the user’s embedded reference library (local vector search, — queries, 0 excerpts retained), then (2) a web and database round (scholarly indexes, patents, agency and industry documents) to complete the process description. Each reference was verified (DOI against Crossref; patents against the patent office record; other documents fetched and the quoted passage found in the text). Reference statistics: 9 references, 6 Crossref-verified articles, 2 patents, 1 grey documents. | ||
| - | |||
| - | ==== 4.2 Calculation procedures ==== | ||
| - | |||
| - | === 4.2.1 Stoichiometry and mass/ | ||
| - | |||
| - | Stoichiometric model of the dataset (spec.json), | ||
| - | |||
| - | ^ Balance ^ In (kg) ^ Out (kg) ^ Residual (%) ^ | ||
| - | | C | — | — | -0 | | ||
| - | | H | — | — | -0 | | ||
| - | | N | — | — | 0 | | ||
| - | | O | — | — | -0 | | ||
| - | | mass | — | — | -0 | | ||
| - | |||
| - | === 4.2.2 Energy model === | ||
| - | |||
| - | Heat and electricity are computed per consumer from process physics with the tdc energy model (Annex A); each parameter is cited or declared as an assumption. | ||
| - | |||
| - | ^ Consumer ^ Energy form ^ Duty / power ^ Time ^ Energy per kg ^ Source ^ | ||
| - | | [Fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | | [Fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | | [Fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | | [Fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | | [Fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | | [Fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | | [Fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | | [Fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | | [Exhaust gas treatment 1] First off-gas treatment (quench/ | ||
| - | | [Exhaust gas treatment 2 (regenerative thermal oxidizer)] Regenerative thermal oxidizer NG fuel (on-site, 2.06 kg NG per kg product) | heat (fuel) | — | — | 5.908 MJ | [Sourced on-site RTO fuel (carrier fuel). Per user decision 4 carried by the energy model fuel_supply as BAFU heat per MJ. This plus the step] | | ||
| - | | [Exhaust gas treatment 2 (regenerative thermal oxidizer)] RTO fans and blower (off-gas and oxidising-air circulation) | electricity (utility) | — | — | 0.0262 kWh | [RTO fans and post-treatment blower of the regenerative thermal oxidizer; the sourced RSC_ESI_2016 abatement system (25 kW at 12.5 kg/h) incl] | | ||
| - | | [Fiber drying and sizing] Sizing-bath water heating (technical drying, recovered closed loop) | heat (electric) | — | — | 1.2 MJ | [The sizing-bath water is a recovered closed loop: ’the water evaporates in technical drying, is recovered and fed back; the coating remains ] | | ||
| - | | [Fiber drying and sizing] Drying air handling + winding drives (sourced RSC stage powers) | electricity | 1.2 | 1 | 1.2 kWh | [RSC_ESI_2016 Table 1 sourced stage powers (measured, 100 t/a pilot line) - INDEPENDENT of the Benitez2021 benchmark. SHARED winding/ | ||
| - | | [Graphitisation (high-modulus grade, no benchmark counterpart)] Graphitisation furnace electric power, HM grade (graphite-block furnace at 2000-2800 C) | electricity | 20 | 1 | 20 kWh | [YongXian2026 sourced specific power range (the defining energy sink of the high-modulus grades). No HM graphitisation furnace dimensions, U-] | | ||
| - | |||
| - | Totals per kg: heat 70.74 MJ, electricity 49.35 kWh, primary energy — MJ. | ||
| - | |||
| - | === 4.2.3 Emissions === | ||
| - | |||
| - | Direct emissions: Nitrogen, off-gas (to air) 0.7345 kg; Carbon dioxide, fossil (to air) 3.155 kg; Water, off-gas vapor (to air) 1.411 kg; Nitrogen oxides, fossil (to air) 0.00012 kg; Hydrogen cyanide (to air) 0.00191 kg; Carbon monoxide, fossil (to air) 0.1339 kg; Ammonia (to air) 0.001357 kg; Methane (to air) 0.001717 kg; Ethylene (to air) 0.001711 kg; Ethane (to air) 0.001714 kg; Nitrogen, liquid, at plant (to air) 8.822 kg. | ||
| - | |||
| - | === 4.2.4 Transport === | ||
| - | |||
| - | Statistical transport from the provenance of each raw material to the plant region (Annex C): Transport, freight, rail 0.01056 tkm; Transport, barge 0.01188 tkm; Transport, transoceanic freight ship 0.1113 tkm; Transport, freight, lorry, diesel, 40t gross weight, 2006, EURO-IV, long haul 0.0117 tkm | ||
| - | |||
| - | === 4.2.5 Infrastructure === | ||
| - | |||
| - | Chemical plant, organics 1.2e-09 p | ||
| - | |||
| - | ==== 4.3 Inventory table ==== | ||
| - | |||
| - | Per 1 kg of product. GSD² = squared geometric standard deviation of the lognormal distribution; | ||
| - | |||
| - | ^ Exchange ^ Direction ^ Amount ^ Unit ^ BAFU dataset / elementary flow ^ GSD² ^ Pedigree ^ Source ^ | ||
| - | | Nitrogen, off-gas (to air) | output | 0.73455 | kg | Nitrogen | 1.57 | (4,3,2,1,1) | [—] | | ||
| - | | Chemical plant, organics | input | 1.2e-09 | p | Chemical plant, organics [RER] | 3.06 | (4,3,3,1,1) | [—] | | ||
| - | | Water, process, for surface treatment and sizing | input | 5.5 | kg | Water, deionised, at plant [CH] | 1.13 | (3,3,2,1,1) | [—] | | ||
| - | | Transport, freight, rail | input | 0.010565 | tkm | Transport, freight, rail [RER] | 2.02 | (3,3,2,2,1) | [—] | | ||
| - | | Transport, barge | input | 0.011885 | tkm | Transport, barge [RER] | 2.02 | (3,3,2,2,1) | [—] | | ||
| - | | Transport, transoceanic freight ship | input | 0.11131 | tkm | Transport, transoceanic freight ship [OCE] | 2.02 | (3,3,2,2,1) | [—] | | ||
| - | | Wastewater treatment, class 3 | input | 0.0055 | m3 | Treatment, sewage, to wastewater treatment, class 3 [CH] | 1.13 | (3,3,2,1,1) | [—] | | ||
| - | | Transport, freight, lorry, diesel, 40t gross weight, 2006, EURO-IV, long haul | input | 0.011703 | tkm | Transport, freight, lorry, diesel, 40t gross weight, 2006, EURO-IV, long haul [RER] | 3.02 | (3,3,2,2,1) | [—] | | ||
| - | | Sizing agent, epoxy | input | 0.016 | kg | Epoxy resin, liquid, at plant [RER] | 1.13 | (3,3,2,1,1) | [—] | | ||
| - | | Oxygen, resource in air | input | 3.6248 | kg | Oxygen | 1.22 | (4,3,2,1,1) | [—] | | ||
| - | | Nitrogen, liquid, at plant | input | 8.822 | kg | Nitrogen, liquid, at plant [RER] | 1.13 | (3,3,2,1,1) | [—] | | ||
| - | | Ammonium bicarbonate, | ||
| - | | Ethylene glycol, at plant | input | 0.0076 | kg | Ethylene glycol, at plant [RER] | 1.13 | (3,3,2,1,1) | [—] | | ||
| - | | Carbon dioxide, fossil (to air) | output | 3.1553 | kg | Carbon dioxide, fossil | 1.22 | (4,3,2,1,1) | [—] | | ||
| - | | Water, off-gas vapor (to air) | output | 1.4107 | kg | Water | 1.57 | (4,3,2,1,1) | [—] | | ||
| - | | Nitrogen oxides, fossil (to air) | output | 0.00012 | kg | Nitrogen oxides | 1.57 | (4,3,2,1,1) | [—] | | ||
| - | | Hydrogen cyanide (to air) | output | 0.00191 | kg | Cyanide | 1.57 | (4,3,2,1,1) | [—] | | ||
| - | | Carbon monoxide, fossil (to air) | output | 0.13386 | kg | Carbon monoxide, fossil | 5.06 | (4,3,2,1,1) | [—] | | ||
| - | | Ammonia (to air) | output | 0.001357 | kg | Ammonia | 1.57 | (4,3,2,1,1) | [—] | | ||
| - | | Methane (to air) | output | 0.001717 | kg | Methane, fossil | 1.57 | (4,3,2,1,1) | [—] | | ||
| - | | Ethylene (to air) | output | 0.001711 | kg | NMVOC, non-methane volatile organic compounds | 1.57 | (4,3,2,1,1) | [—] | | ||
| - | | Ethane (to air) | output | 0.001714 | kg | Ethane | 2.05 | (4,3,2,1,1) | [—] | | ||
| - | | Electricity, | ||
| - | | Heat, natural gas, at heat plant | input | 70.742 | MJ | Natural gas, burned in boiler modulating >100kW [RER] | 1.13 | (3,3,2,1,1) | [—] | | ||
| - | | Nitrogen, liquid, at plant (to air) | output | 8.822 | kg | Nitrogen | 1.57 | (4,3,2,1,1) | [—] | | ||
| - | | PAN precursor fiber, wet spun | input | 2.802 | kg | tdc dataset cf-v2-precursor-ras | 1.22 | (4,3,2,1,1) | [—] | | ||
| - | |||
| - | ==== 4.4 Data quality assessment ==== | ||
| - | |||
| - | Energy verification per sub-process (policy B): Fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | |||
| - | ==== 4.5 Data gaps and assumptions register ==== | ||
| - | |||
| - | ^ Item ^ Class ^ Value used ^ Reason / queries tried ^ Effect (Section 6.3) ^ | ||
| - | |||
| - | ==== 4.6 Validation of data (ISO 14044 4.3.3.2) ==== | ||
| - | |||
| - | * Mass and element balances: Section 4.2.1. | ||
| - | * Cross-check with independent data: BAFU datasets of similar processes (Carbon fiber production, fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | * Independent second-model review (Gemma-4-26B-A4B-it-GGUF): | ||
| - | * Citation test: every quoted excerpt was found in its source text (all found). | ||
| - | * Independent recalculation by tdc-doc: independent recalculation of GWP100 = pipeline LCIA (lcia.json): | ||
| - | |||
| - | ===== 5 Life cycle impact assessment (EF v3.1) ===== | ||
| - | |||
| - | Characterisation results per 1 kg, computed with bw2calc on the BAFU 2026 v1 database (Mutel 2017; European Commission, Joint Research Centre 2022). | ||
| - | |||
| - | ^ Impact category ^ Indicator ^ Unit ^ Result ^ | ||
| - | | acidification | accumulated exceedance (AE) | mol H+-Eq | 0.2006 | | ||
| - | | climate change | global warming potential (GWP100) | kg CO2-Eq | 78.46 | | ||
| - | | climate change: biogenic | global warming potential (GWP100) | kg CO2-Eq | 0.2354 | | ||
| - | | climate change: fossil | global warming potential (GWP100) | kg CO2-Eq | 78.21 | | ||
| - | | climate change: land use and land use change | global warming potential (GWP100) | kg CO2-Eq | 0.0109 | | ||
| - | | ecotoxicity: | ||
| - | | ecotoxicity: | ||
| - | | ecotoxicity: | ||
| - | | energy resources: non-renewable | abiotic depletion potential (ADP): fossil fuels | MJ, net calorific value | 1154 | | ||
| - | | eutrophication: | ||
| - | | eutrophication: | ||
| - | | eutrophication: | ||
| - | | human toxicity: carcinogenic | comparative toxic unit for human (CTUh) | CTUh | 3.114e-08 | | ||
| - | | human toxicity: carcinogenic, | ||
| - | | human toxicity: carcinogenic, | ||
| - | | human toxicity: non-carcinogenic | comparative toxic unit for human (CTUh) | CTUh | 7.254e-07 | | ||
| - | | human toxicity: non-carcinogenic, | ||
| - | | human toxicity: non-carcinogenic, | ||
| - | | ionising radiation: human health | human exposure efficiency relative to u235 | kBq U235-Eq | 11.3 | | ||
| - | | land use | soil quality index | dimensionless | 207.2 | | ||
| - | | material resources: metals/ | ||
| - | | ozone depletion | ozone depletion potential (ODP) | kg CFC-11-Eq | 1.122e-06 | | ||
| - | | particulate matter formation | impact on human health | disease incidence | 1.783e-06 | | ||
| - | | photochemical oxidant formation: human health | tropospheric ozone concentration increase | kg NMVOC-Eq | 0.1321 | | ||
| - | | water use | user deprivation potential (deprivation-weighted water consumption) | m3 world eq. deprived | 7.524 | | ||
| - | |||
| - | {{ : | ||
| - | |||
| - | // | ||
| - | |||
| - | Climate change 78.46 kg CO2-eq per kg. Main contributors: | ||
| - | |||
| - | ===== 6 Interpretation (ISO 14044, 4.5) ===== | ||
| - | |||
| - | ==== 6.1 Significant issues ==== | ||
| - | |||
| - | The inventory items that dominate climate change are Electricity, | ||
| - | |||
| - | ==== 6.2 Completeness check ==== | ||
| - | |||
| - | board stage ‘inventory’ (closed + automatic check re-run): PASS; inventory completeness (classes, no zero amounts): PASS; every exchange scored in EF v3.1 (linked to BAFU / biosphere): PASS | ||
| - | |||
| - | ==== 6.3 Sensitivity check ==== | ||
| - | |||
| - | One-at-a-time variation of (a) every assumption of Section 4.6 over its plausible range and (b) every parameter for which the literature gives a range or several values (Annex D); scenarios for alternative routes, feedstocks and regions. | ||
| - | |||
| - | ^ Parameter ^ Base ^ Low / high ^ Source of the range ^ Δ GWP100 (%) ^ Δ other categories (max %) ^ | ||
| - | | Graphitisation (high-modulus grade, no benchmark counterpart): | ||
| - | | PAN precursor fiber, wet spun (pedigree 95 % interval) | 2.80201 | /1.22 / x1.22 | [pedigree (Annex H)] | -7.3 / +8.9 | 20.4 | | ||
| - | | Electricity, | ||
| - | | Fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | | Exhaust gas treatment 2 (regenerative thermal oxidizer): electricity_kWh (per kg step output) | 0.0262 | 0.0262 / 0.1885 | [Benitez A, Wulf C, de Palmenaer A, et al. Ecologic; RSC_ESI_2016 Table 1 ‘Abatement system 25 kW’ at 1] | +0.0 / +1.6 | 2.7 | | ||
| - | | Fiber drying and sizing: electricity_kWh (per kg step output) | 1.5922 | 0.6257 / 0.6257 | [Benitez A, Wulf C, de Palmenaer A, et al. Ecologic] | -0.9 / -0.9 | 1.5 | | ||
| - | | Carbon dioxide, fossil (to air) (pedigree 95 % interval) | 3.15527 | /1.22 / x1.22 | [pedigree (Annex H)] | -0.7 / +0.9 | 0.9 | | ||
| - | | Heat, natural gas, at heat plant (pedigree 95 % interval) | 70.74159 | /1.13 / x1.13 | [pedigree (Annex H)] | -0.8 / +0.8 | 2.2 | | ||
| - | | Nitrogen, liquid, at plant (pedigree 95 % interval) | 8.822 | /1.13 / x1.13 | [pedigree (Annex H)] | -0.3 / +0.3 | 3.0 | | ||
| - | | Chemical plant, organics (pedigree 95 % interval) | 0.0 | /3.06 / x3.06 | [pedigree (Annex H)] | -0.1 / +0.3 | 28.1 | | ||
| - | | Exhaust gas treatment 1: electricity_kWh (per kg step output) | 0.023 | 0.02 / 0.0229 | [Benitez A, Wulf C, de Palmenaer A, et al. Ecologic; Benitez2021 benchmark sub-process ‘carbon fiber pr; RSC_ESI_2016 Table 1 ’Abatement system 25 kW’ at 1] | -0.1 / -0.0 | 0.2 | | ||
| - | |||
| - | ==== 6.4 Consistency check ==== | ||
| - | |||
| - | Final control: 22 item(s) passed; no failure. | ||
| - | |||
| - | ==== 6.5 Uncertainty analysis ==== | ||
| - | |||
| - | Monte Carlo simulation (1000 runs) on the lognormal distributions of all exchanges: | ||
| - | |||
| - | ^ Impact category ^ Median ^ 2.5 % ^ 97.5 % ^ GSD² ^ | ||
| - | | acidification / accumulated exceedance (AE) | 0.2018 | 0.1803 | 0.2274 | 1.12 | | ||
| - | | climate change / global warming potential (GWP100) | 78.81 | 71.37 | 87.39 | 1.11 | | ||
| - | | climate change: biogenic / global warming potential (GWP100) | 0.2364 | 0.217 | 0.2572 | 1.09 | | ||
| - | | climate change: fossil / global warming potential (GWP100) | 78.56 | 71.14 | 87.13 | 1.11 | | ||
| - | | climate change: land use and land use change / global warming potential (GWP100) | 0.01096 | 0.00993 | 0.01215 | 1.11 | | ||
| - | | ecotoxicity: | ||
| - | | ecotoxicity: | ||
| - | | ecotoxicity: | ||
| - | | energy resources: non-renewable / abiotic depletion potential (ADP): fossil fuels | 1160 | 1039 | 1301 | 1.12 | | ||
| - | | eutrophication: | ||
| - | | eutrophication: | ||
| - | | eutrophication: | ||
| - | | human toxicity: carcinogenic / comparative toxic unit for human (CTUh) | 3.129e-08 | 2.859e-08 | 3.429e-08 | 1.1 | | ||
| - | | human toxicity: carcinogenic, | ||
| - | | human toxicity: carcinogenic, | ||
| - | | human toxicity: non-carcinogenic / comparative toxic unit for human (CTUh) | 7.285e-07 | 6.635e-07 | 8.022e-07 | 1.1 | | ||
| - | | human toxicity: non-carcinogenic, | ||
| - | | human toxicity: non-carcinogenic, | ||
| - | | ionising radiation: human health / human exposure efficiency relative to u235 | 11.37 | 10.37 | 12.48 | 1.1 | | ||
| - | | land use / soil quality index | 207.9 | 190.8 | 228.1 | 1.09 | | ||
| - | | material resources: metals/ | ||
| - | | ozone depletion / ozone depletion potential (ODP) | 1.127e-06 | 1e-06 | 1.286e-06 | 1.13 | | ||
| - | | particulate matter formation / impact on human health | 1.793e-06 | 1.603e-06 | 2.021e-06 | 1.12 | | ||
| - | | photochemical oxidant formation: human health / tropospheric ozone concentration increase | 0.1342 | 0.1195 | 0.1584 | 1.15 | | ||
| - | | water use / user deprivation potential (deprivation-weighted water consumption) | 7.551 | 6.903 | 8.292 | 1.1 | | ||
| - | |||
| - | ==== 6.6 Comparison with other data ==== | ||
| - | |||
| - | ^ Source ^ Scope ^ Value (GWP100 or energy) ^ This dataset ^ Ratio ^ Explanation ^ | ||
| - | | [BAFU 2026 dataset] | Carbon fiber, weaved, at factory (RER), cradle-to-gate incl. weaving | 51.5 kg CO2-eq | 78.5 | 1.52 | BAFU analog (Benitez 2021 inventory); includes weaving | | ||
| - | | [tdc dataset] | cf-v2-hm-rer (same product, other region) | 56.8 kg CO2-eq | 78.5 | 1.38 | regional variant (electricity, | ||
| - | | [tdc dataset] | cf-v2-hm-rna (same product, other region) | 59.3 kg CO2-eq | 78.5 | 1.32 | regional variant (electricity, | ||
| - | | [Benitez et al. 2021] | electricity, | ||
| - | |||
| - | ==== 6.7 Conclusions, | ||
| - | |||
| - | GWP100 78.5 kg CO2-eq per kg (95 % interval 71.4–87.4). Dominant contributors: | ||
| - | |||
| - | ===== 7 Critical review ===== | ||
| - | |||
| - | //Reserved for the external reviewer (ISO 14044 clause 6; ISO/TS 14071 (//ISO/TS 14071:2014 Environmental Management — Life Cycle Assessment — Critical Review Processes and Reviewer Competencies// | ||
| - | |||
| - | ^ Reviewer comment ^ Response ^ Change in the dataset ^ | ||
| - | | | | | | ||
| - | |||
| - | ===== 8 References ===== | ||
| - | |||
| - | Bell, Caleb. 2016a. //Fluids: Fluid Dynamics Component of Chemical Engineering Design Library (ChEDL)//. Released. [[https:// | ||
| - | |||
| - | Bell, Caleb. 2016b. //Thermo: Chemical Properties Component of Chemical Engineering Design Library (ChEDL)//. Released. [[https:// | ||
| - | |||
| - | Benitez A, Wulf C, de Palmenaer A, Lengersdorf M, Röding T, Grube T, et al. 2021. ‘Ecological Assessment of Fuel Cell Electric Vehicles with Special Focus on Type IV Carbon Fiber Hydrogen Tank’. //Journal of Cleaner Production// | ||
| - | |||
| - | Bo Guan et al. 2025. ‘Design and Numerical Study of Induction-Heating Graphitization Furnace Based on Graphene Coils’. // | ||
| - | |||
| - | Commission Recommendation (EU) 2021/2279 of 15 December 2021 on the Use of the Environmental Footprint Methods to Measure and Communicate the Life Cycle Environmental Performance of Products and Organisations, | ||
| - | |||
| - | European Commission, Joint Research Centre. 2022. // | ||
| - | |||
| - | Frischknecht, | ||
| - | |||
| - | Groetsch T., Maghe M., Rana R., Hess R., Nunna S., Herron J., Buckmaster D., Creighton C., Varley R. 2021. ‘Gas Emission Study of the Polyacrylonitrile-Based Continuous Pilot-Scale Carbon Fiber Manufacturing Process’. In //Ind. Eng. Chem. Res.//, vol. 60. [[https:// | ||
| - | |||
| - | //ISO 14040:2006 Environmental Management — Life Cycle Assessment — Principles and Framework (Incl. Amd 1:2020)//. 2006. International Organization for Standardization. | ||
| - | |||
| - | //ISO 14044:2006 Environmental Management — Life Cycle Assessment — Requirements and Guidelines (Incl. Amd 1:2017, Amd 2:2020)//. 2006. International Organization for Standardization. | ||
| - | |||
| - | //ISO/TS 14071:2014 Environmental Management — Life Cycle Assessment — Critical Review Processes and Reviewer Competencies// | ||
| - | |||
| - | Kumar S., Chae H., Newcomb B., Gulgunje P., Liu Y., Gupta K., Kamath M. (Georgia Tech Research Institute). 2016. High strength and high modulus carbon fibers (WO2016057696A1). issued 2016. [[https:// | ||
| - | |||
| - | Mutel, Chris. 2017. ‘Brightway: | ||
| - | |||
| - | Nunna S., Blanchard P., Buckmaster D., Davis S., Naebe M. 2019. ‘Development of a Cost Model for the Production of Carbon Fibres’. In // | ||
| - | |||
| - | Paul, Edward L., Victor A. Atiemo-Obeng, | ||
| - | |||
| - | Prenzel T., Hohmann A., Prescher T., Angerer K., Wehner D., Ilg R., von Reden T., Drechsler K., Albrecht S. 2023. ‘Bringing Light into the Dark - Overview of Environmental Impacts of Carbon Fiber Production and Potential Levers for Reduction’. In // | ||
| - | |||
| - | Toray CMA. 2025. ‘TORAYCA M40J High Modulus Carbon Fiber Data Sheet’. In //Toray Product Data Sheet (Rev. 04/ | ||
| - | |||
| - | Toray Industries, Inc. 1990. Process for producing high-strength, | ||
| - | |||
| - | Yang S, Weimin Yang, Sanyang Li, Liangbo Yao, Haoyi Li, Lisheng Cheng, Hua Yan, Weiyu Cao, Jing Tan. 2018. ‘Laser Induced Graphitization of PAN-Based Carbon Fibers’. //RSC Advances// 8: 11543–50. [[https:// | ||
| - | |||
| - | ===== Annex A — Energy consumption model ===== | ||
| - | |||
| - | The tdc energy model computes the heat and electricity demand per functional unit from process physics, in two layers, as process simulators do. | ||
| - | |||
| - | **Layer 1 — thermodynamic duties of each step.** Sensible heat //Q// = //m// // | ||
| - | |||
| - | **Layer 2 — conversion of duties into purchased energy.** Heat supply // | ||
| - | |||
| - | * agitation: //P// = // | ||
| - | * pumps: //P// = // | ||
| - | * vacuum: isothermal compression of the vapour/gas load //P// = // | ||
| - | * cooling: electricity per MJ of heat rejected; installed equipment at part load; plant utilities per tonne, each only with a source. | ||
| - | |||
| - | All expressions are unit-checked with //pint//. Result per kg: heat, electricity, | ||
| - | |||
| - | ^ Parameter ^ Value ^ Unit ^ Source / assumption ^ | ||
| - | | [Fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | | [Fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | | [Fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | | [Fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | | [Fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | | [Fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | | [Fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | | [Fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | | [Exhaust gas treatment 1] First off-gas treatment (quench/ | ||
| - | | [Exhaust gas treatment 2 (regenerative thermal oxidizer)] Regenerative thermal oxidizer NG fuel (on-site, 2.06 kg NG per kg product) (duty) | {‘MJ’: 5.9082} | per kg of step output | Sourced on-site RTO fuel (carrier fuel). Per user decision 4 carried by the energy model fuel_supply as BAFU heat per MJ. This plus the step-1 stabilization NG (0.22 kg) = the on-site fuel combusted i | | ||
| - | | [Exhaust gas treatment 2 (regenerative thermal oxidizer)] RTO fans and blower (off-gas and oxidising-air circulation) (specific) | {‘quantity_per_batch’: | ||
| - | | [Fiber drying and sizing] Sizing-bath water heating (technical drying, recovered closed loop) (loss) | {‘MJ’: 1.2} | per kg of step output | The sizing-bath water is a recovered closed loop: ‘the water evaporates in technical drying, is recovered and fed back; the coating remains on the fiber’ (Prenzel2023 sec 3.1.3). 1.2 MJ per kg product | | ||
| - | | [Fiber drying and sizing] Drying air handling + winding drives (sourced RSC stage powers) (motor) | {‘P_kW’: | ||
| - | | [Graphitisation (high-modulus grade, no benchmark counterpart)] Graphitisation furnace electric power, HM grade (graphite-block furnace at 2000-2800 C) (installed) | {‘kW_installed’: | ||
| - | |||
| - | ===== Annex B — Stoichiometry specification and balances ===== | ||
| - | |||
| - | < | ||
| - | { | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | }, | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | { | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | }, | ||
| - | { | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | }, | ||
| - | { | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | }, | ||
| - | { | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | }, | ||
| - | { | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | }, | ||
| - | { | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | } | ||
| - | ], | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | { | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | }, | ||
| - | { | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | }, | ||
| - | { | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | }, | ||
| - | { | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | }, | ||
| - | { | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | }, | ||
| - | { | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | }, | ||
| - | { | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | }, | ||
| - | { | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | }, | ||
| - | { | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | }, | ||
| - | { | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | " | ||
| - | } | ||
| - | ] | ||
| - | } | ||
| - | </ | ||
| - | |||
| - | ===== Annex C — Transport calculation (raw-material provenance) ===== | ||
| - | |||
| - | Provenance of each raw material in the supply of the region: supply_transport (Eurostat Comext / UN Comtrade provenance shares, PEF legs). Legs: default scenario of the PEF method (Commission Recommendation (EU) 2021/2279 of 15 December 2021 on the Use of the Environmental Footprint Methods to Measure and Communicate the Life Cycle Environmental Performance of Products and Organisations 2021) (European suppliers 130 km truck, 240 km train, 270 km barge; overseas suppliers 1000 km truck plus the sea route from the origin’s main port, computed on the marine network). | ||
| - | |||
| - | ^ Raw material ^ HS code ^ Regional share ^ Overseas share ^ Main partners ^ Mean sea distance (km) ^ Source ^ | ||
| - | |||
| - | ===== Annex D — Source excerpts ===== | ||
| - | |||
| - | Every value taken from a source, with the verbatim passage it relies on (also attached as notes to the references in the Zotero library). | ||
| - | |||
| - | ^ Reference ^ Page / section ^ Excerpt ^ Used for ^ | ||
| - | | (Prenzel T., Hohmann A., Prescher T., Angerer K., Wehner D., Ilg R., von Reden T., Drechsler K., Albrecht S. 2023) | Sec 3.1.1, output flows | “Various authors have provided quantification for this mass loss between 40 and 55 wt.% (c.f. Appendix A).” | precursor input 2.00 kg/kg CF (50% mass loss central estimate) | | ||
| - | | (Prenzel T., Hohmann A., Prescher T., Angerer K., Wehner D., Ilg R., von Reden T., Drechsler K., Albrecht S. 2023) | Sec 3.2, energy demand | “a plausible average value for the total energy demand for the production of 12 k and 24 k HT-fibers was determined to be 170 MJ of thermal and electric per kg carbon fiber” | energy.json: | ||
| - | | (Prenzel T., Hohmann A., Prescher T., Angerer K., Wehner D., Ilg R., von Reden T., Drechsler K., Albrecht S. 2023) | Sec 3.2, emissions | “A common practice is treatment by proprietary regenerative thermal oxidizers, offering more than 95% efficiency” | off-gas treatment: 95% destruction of CO/HCN/NH3 in the modeled stoich net emissions | | ||
| - | | (Prenzel T., Hohmann A., Prescher T., Angerer K., Wehner D., Ilg R., von Reden T., Drechsler K., Albrecht S. 2023) | Table 1, LCI for 1 kg CF | “Electrolyte [Ammonium bicarbonate] 0.03 kg/kg CF; Sizing agent [Epoxy resin] 0.02 kg/kg CF; Water [H2O] 5.5 kg/kg CF; Wastewater 5.5 kg/kg CF” | electrolyte 0.03 kg, sizing 0.02 kg, water 5.5 kg, wastewater 5.5 kg per kg CF | | ||
| - | | (Prenzel T., Hohmann A., Prescher T., Angerer K., Wehner D., Ilg R., von Reden T., Drechsler K., Albrecht S. 2023) | Table 1, LCI for 1 kg CF (Input rows) | “Polyacrylonitrile (PAN) fiber 1.95 kg/kg CF; Air 9.6 kg/kg CF; Nitrogen [N2] 10.0 kg/kg CF” | precursor input ratio 1.95 kg/kg CF (industry-approved LCI); basis for the HM precursor exchange (2.0 kg/kg after the C25H3 carbon-content closure) | | ||
| - | | (Prenzel T., Hohmann A., Prescher T., Angerer K., Wehner D., Ilg R., von Reden T., Drechsler K., Albrecht S. 2023) | Sec 3.1, process description | “Depending on the desired product, additional heating, also called graphitization, | ||
| - | | (Groetsch T., Maghe M., Rana R., Hess R., Nunna S., Herron J., Buckmaster D., Creighton C., Varley R. 2021) | title | “Gas Emission Study of the Polyacrylonitrile-Based Continuous Pilot-Scale Carbon Fiber Manufacturing Process” | peer-reviewed cross-check of the stabilization/ | ||
| - | | (Nunna S., Blanchard P., Buckmaster D., Davis S., Naebe M. 2019) | sec 1, introduction | “Polyacrylonitrile (PAN) is currently considered to be the most suitable precursor for the manufacture of carbon fibres, at least 90% of the current carbon fibre production is based on PAN precursor fibres” | route selection: PAN = >90% of carbon fiber production (dominant route, market.md) | | ||
| - | | (Nunna S., Blanchard P., Buckmaster D., Davis S., Naebe M. 2019) | sec 4, cost contribution | “the precursor contributes to 53.4% of the total cost of carbon fibre” | precursor is the dominant input per kg CF (sensitivity context, QA report) | | ||
| - | | (Toray Industries, Inc. 1990) | title, US4917836A | “Process for producing high-strength, | ||
| - | | (Kumar S., Chae H., Newcomb B., Gulgunje P., Liu Y., Gupta K., Kamath M. (Georgia Tech Research Institute) 2016) | title, WO2016057696A1 | “High strength and high modulus carbon fibers” | patent confirmation of HM grade fiber production (graphitisation-based modulus increase) | | ||
| - | | (Toray CMA 2025) | M40J data sheet, properties | “Tensile Strength 4,400 MPa; Tensile Modulus 377 GPa; Strain at Failure 1.2%; Density 1.77 g/cm3; Filament Diameter 5 um; Chemical Composition: | ||
| - | | [nunna_2018_stabilization_energy] | 1 | “stabilization is considered to be the most time- and energy-consuming step, as it consumes almost 48% of energy during PAN to carbon fiber conversion” | energy-literature-based justification: | ||
| - | | (Benitez A, Wulf C, de Palmenaer A, Lengersdorf M, Röding T, Grube T, et al. 2021) | | “carbon fiber production, fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | | (Benitez A, Wulf C, de Palmenaer A, Lengersdorf M, Röding T, Grube T, et al. 2021) | | “exhaust gas treatment 2: 0.0262 kWh + 0.1908 kg natural gas + 0.0928 m3 compressed air per kg output (10.61 kg per kg final CF)” | exhaust gas treatment 2 incinerator support fuel 0.190816 kg gas/kg output (published step inventory) | | ||
| - | | (Yang S, Weimin Yang, Sanyang Li, Liangbo Yao, Haoyi Li, Lisheng Cheng, Hua Yan, Weiyu Cao, Jing Tan 2018) | | “To obtain high modulus graphite fibers, graphitization is normally carried out at 2000–3000 °C in a furnace which was made by graphite tube as a heating unit” | graphitisation temperature 2000-3000 C in a graphite-tube resistance furnace (2500 C used, middle of the band); high-modulus grade requires the extra heat treatment | | ||
| - | | (Bo Guan et al. 2025) | 1 | “3-8 MWh per ton of graphite product produced” | graphitisation step independent reference: 3-8 MJ/kg purchased energy (mid 1.53 kWh/kg) | | ||
| - | | (Prenzel T., Hohmann A., Prescher T., Angerer K., Wehner D., Ilg R., von Reden T., Drechsler K., Albrecht S. 2023) | 4 | “gas is always required to support firing” | oven heating technology = natural-gas fired (vs Benitez T700G electric ovens): explains why combined-step electricity is far below the Benitez benchmark | | ||
| - | | (Nunna S., Blanchard P., Buckmaster D., Davis S., Naebe M. 2019) | 5 | “155.5 MWh/day” | whole-process electricity fleet-average cross-check (incl N2 generation) ~20.4 kWh/kg | | ||
| - | | [RSC_ESI_2016] | | “Stage of the carbon fibre process Energy consumption (Kw) Stabilisation 134 Low temperature carbonisation 15 High temperature carbonisation 45 Abatement system 25 Material handling 5 Surface treatment, handling, drying 43 Winding 10 Total 277” | sourced stage powers of the 100 t/a pilot line (12.5 kg/h): stabilization 134 kW, LT 15, HT 45, abatement 25, handling 5, surface treatment/ | ||
| - | | [IJAEM2021] | | “Over 93% of the total energy consumed spent on heating the air and only about 3% on heating the processed material” | stabilization oven energy split: back-derive the recirculating air flow from the sourced 134 kW stabilization stage power | | ||
| - | | [CN102051711B] | | “This pre-oxidation process adopts electric furnace heating wire and far infrared assistant heating pattern” | carrier of the stabilization oven: electric heating wire + far infrared (electric, not gas); same patent family as the far-infrared carbonisation heating | | ||
| - | | [YongXian2026] | | “High modulus carbon fibre (380-450 GPa) requires an additional graphitization step at 2000-2800 C, which adds 15-35 kWh per kilogram to the energy budget” | graphitisation specific power of the HM-grade stage: 15-35 kWh/kg at 2000-2800 C (CF-specific range; the defining energy sink of the high-modulus grades) | | ||
| - | | [Li2024] | | “Graphitization requires heating temperatures typically up to 2800 C or higher, which is an energy-intensive process requiring 3-8 MWh per ton of graphite product produced” | independent graphitisation unit-operation reference: 3-8 kWh/kg graphite product (induction graphitisation furnaces), distinct source from YongXian2026 | | ||
| - | |||
| - | ===== Annex E — Independent second-model review ===== | ||
| - | |||
| - | ^ # ^ Severity ^ Exchange ^ Finding ^ Answer / change ^ | ||
| - | | 1 | medium | Water, process, for surface treatment and sizing | The amount (5.5 kg) is significantly higher than the values found in the cross-check for other sub-processes (8.11e-05 to 0.00025 kg), although it matches the Prenzel 2023 literature. This suggests a potential scale or boundary mismatch between the full process and the sub-process datasets. | Not an error - boundary/ | ||
| - | | 2 | low | Electricity, | ||
| - | |||
| - | ===== Annex F — Cross-check with independent data ===== | ||
| - | |||
| - | Independent analogs (BAFU): [‘Carbon fiber production, fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | |||
| - | ^ exchange / class ^ this dataset (per kg) ^ independent value(s) ^ source ^ status ^ | ||
| - | | electricity | 49.35 | 0.02291 - 28.23 | Carbon fiber production, fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | | transport | 0.1455 | 0.007105 - 1.26 | Carbon fiber production, fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | | water | 5.5 | 8.114e-05 - 0.0002505 | Carbon fiber production, fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | | Electricity, | ||
| - | | Sizing agent, epoxy | 0.016 | 0.02 kg | Prenzel 2023 Table 1: Sizing agent [Epoxy resin] 0.02 kg/kg | ok | | ||
| - | | Ammonium bicarbonate, | ||
| - | | Water, process, for surface treatment and sizing | 5.5 | 5.5 kg | Prenzel 2023 Table 1: Water [H2O] 5.5 kg/kg CF | ok | | ||
| - | | Wastewater treatment, class 3 | 0.0055 | 0.0055 m3 | Prenzel 2023 Table 1: Wastewater 5.5 kg/kg CF, converted at | ok | | ||
| - | | Heat, natural gas, at heat plant | 70.741586 | 102.0 MJ | Prenzel 2023 Table 1 + sec 3.2: 170 MJ/kg total; 60% heat sh | ok | | ||
| - | | Electricity, | ||
| - | | Sizing agent, epoxy | 0.016 | 0.02 kg | Prenzel 2023 Table 1: Sizing agent [Epoxy resin] 0.02 kg/kg | ok | | ||
| - | | Ammonium bicarbonate, | ||
| - | | Water, process, for surface treatment and sizing | 5.5 | 5.5 kg | Prenzel 2023 Table 1: Water [H2O] 5.5 kg/kg CF | ok | | ||
| - | | Wastewater treatment, class 3 | 0.0055 | 0.0055 m3 | Prenzel 2023 Table 1: Wastewater 5.5 kg/kg CF, converted at | ok | | ||
| - | | Heat, natural gas, at heat plant | 70.741586 | 102.0 MJ | Prenzel 2023 Table 1 + sec 3.2: 170 MJ/kg total; 60% heat sh | ok | | ||
| - | | Electricity, | ||
| - | | Sizing agent, epoxy | 0.016 | 0.02 kg | Prenzel 2023 Table 1: Sizing agent [Epoxy resin] 0.02 kg/kg | ok | | ||
| - | | Ammonium bicarbonate, | ||
| - | | Water, process, for surface treatment and sizing | 5.5 | 5.5 kg | Prenzel 2023 Table 1: Water [H2O] 5.5 kg/kg CF | ok | | ||
| - | | Wastewater treatment, class 3 | 0.0055 | 0.0055 m3 | Prenzel 2023 Table 1: Wastewater 5.5 kg/kg CF, converted at | ok | | ||
| - | | Heat, natural gas, at heat plant | 70.741586 | 102.0 MJ | Prenzel 2023 Table 1 + sec 3.2: 170 MJ/kg total; 60% heat sh | ok | | ||
| - | | Electricity, | ||
| - | | Sizing agent, epoxy | 0.016 | 0.02 kg | Prenzel 2023 Table 1: Sizing agent [Epoxy resin] 0.02 kg/kg | ok | | ||
| - | | Ammonium bicarbonate, | ||
| - | | Water, process, for surface treatment and sizing | 5.5 | 5.5 kg | Prenzel 2023 Table 1: Water [H2O] 5.5 kg/kg CF | ok | | ||
| - | | Wastewater treatment, class 3 | 0.0055 | 0.0055 m3 | Prenzel 2023 Table 1: Wastewater 5.5 kg/kg CF, converted at | ok | | ||
| - | | Heat, natural gas, at heat plant | 70.741586 | 102.0 MJ | Prenzel 2023 Table 1 + sec 3.2: 170 MJ/kg total; 60% heat sh | ok | | ||
| - | | electricity vs energy.json | 49.35 | 49.35 kWh | tdc energy model | ok | | ||
| - | |||
| - | === 8.0.1 Justified deviations (with evidence) === | ||
| - | |||
| - | * off-gas: Thermal oxidizer with >95% efficiency is the common industry practice (Prenzel 2023). The modeled net emissions are already the treated residuals: CO net 13.1 g/kg is the post-oxidizer value after 95% destruction of the 262 g/kg primary CO; HCN net 6.1 g/kg and NH3 net 2.6 g/kg are also post-oxidizer. No separate oxidizer input exchange is modeled because the support fuel is within the furnace heat of the energy model: 70.74 MJ/kg CF total natural gas at fuel basis, split between the on-site NG stabilization assist (6.73 MJ/kg) and the NG-fired secondary thermal oxidizer / RTO (64.01 MJ/kg). [evidence: prenzel_2023_carbon_fiber_lca] | ||
| - | * Water, process, for surface treatment and sizing: 5.5 kg/kg CF is the published LCI value for the surface-treatment electrolyte + sizing-bath water in the industry-approved LCI (Prenzel 2023 Table 1: Water [H2O] 5.5 kg/kg CF, wastewater 5.5 kg/kg CF). The BAFU sub-process ‘fiber drying and sizing’ models only the residual process water of that unit step, not the full electrolyte/ | ||
| - | * water: 5.5 kg/kg CF is the published LCI value for the surface-treatment electrolyte + sizing-bath water in the industry-approved LCI (Prenzel 2023 Table 1: Water [H2O] 5.5 kg/kg CF, wastewater 5.5 kg/kg CF). The BAFU sub-process ‘fiber drying and sizing’ models only the residual process water of that unit step, not the full electrolyte/ | ||
| - | * family-trend: | ||
| - | * energy-divergence whole process: Model total 248.39 MJ/kg (natural-gas heat 70.74 MJ/kg + electricity 49.35 kWh/kg = 177.6 MJ/kg) is HIGHER than the RSC_ESI_2016 79.8 MJ/kg (277 kW of measured stage powers at 12.5 kg/h, RSC ESI Table 1) because that reference is a measured ELECTRIC subtotal of a 100 t/a STANDARD-modulus PILOT line (tensile modulus 275.39 GPa - RSC ESI source text): it reports stage electric powers only (no fuel), and the line runs NO high-modulus graphitisation stage. This HM dataset = the grade-common stabilization/ | ||
| - | * energy-divergence Exhaust gas treatment 2 (regenerative thermal oxidizer): ET2 off-gas blower + burner/SCR computed as physics from the sourced carbonization off-gas flow (10.83 kg per kg CF) at an assumed 0.05 bar static pressure and 0.7 fan efficiency (DATA GAP - no oxidizer fan nameplate / pressure-drop published). Step heat = the NG-fired secondary thermal oxidizer (VOC/HCN destruction, | ||
| - | * energy-divergence Fiber drying and sizing: Carrier-form difference only. The Benitez2021 benchmark ‘fiber drying and sizing’ step carries its thermal load as STEAM (0.335 MJ steam heat per kg output); in this line the sizing-bath water is a recovered closed loop that is ‘technically dried’ and the drying oven is electrically heated (Prenzel2023 sec 3.1.3; CN102051711B electric heating), so the model’s heat_MJ = 0 and that load sits in the electricity (sizing-bath 1.2 MJ electric + sourced RSC winding/ | ||
| - | |||
| - | Open flags: none | ||
| - | |||
| - | ===== Annex G — Files, tools and audit trail ===== | ||
| - | |||
| - | ^ Item ^ File / tool ^ Version / date ^ | ||
| - | | spec.json | / | ||
| - | | energy.json | / | ||
| - | | energy_result.json | / | ||
| - | | snippets.json | / | ||
| - | | board.json | / | ||
| - | | review.json | / | ||
| - | | lcia.json | / | ||
| - | | cf-v2-hm-ras.ecospold | / | ||
| - | | tdc-doc | / | ||
| - | |||
| - | ===== Annex H — BAFU DQR v2.1 documentation fields (EcoSpold v1 metadata) ===== | ||
| - | |||
| - | ^ DQR field ^ Content ^ | ||
| - | | name | PAN-based carbon fiber, high modulus HM, wet spinning, from regional PAN precursor fiber, 1 kg | | ||
| - | | location | RAS | | ||
| - | | unit | kg | | ||
| - | | time period | 2025 | | ||
| - | | geography | Asia | | ||
| - | | technology | Oxidation carbonisation graphitisation sizing of wet-spun PAN precursor into HM carbon fiber. Region RAS. FU 1 kg. | | ||
| - | | included processes | Fiber stabilization, | ||
| - | | representativeness | Section 3 | | ||
| - | | sources | 9 references (Annex D, References) | | ||
| - | | data generator | tdc pipeline | | ||
| - | | validation | tdc-doc final control: ready for external review | | ||
| - | |||
| - | ===== Comments ===== | ||
| - | |||
| - | Comments are welcome from registered users and appear here once the BAFUquery team has reviewed them. To suggest a dataset that does not exist yet, use [[proposals: | ||
| - | |||
| - | ~~DISCUSSION~~ | ||
datasets/tdc/41de602b-4297-5a5d-984d-d6612bebbce4.1794826957.txt.gz · Last modified: by 127.0.0.1
