OpenData Wiki

Dataset documentation and review before publication

User Tools

Site Tools


datasets:bafu:5048d7ff-2358-3cec-b3ea-0b82687eb3c9

Methanol synthesis, hydrogen from electrolysis, CO2 from MSWI, with heat recovery (100:0 alloc.) — CH

Dataset documentation and final control (tdc-doc, imported mode)
Open this dataset in OpenData

Abstract. BAFU 2026 v1 (Swiss Federal Office for the Environment). Dataset Methanol synthesis, hydrogen from electrolysis, CO2 from MSWI, with heat recovery (100:0 alloc.) [CH], per 1 kg. EF v3.1 climate change 1.385 kg CO2 eq (Monte Carlo 95 % interval 1.076–2.33). Main contributors: Hydrogen production, gaseous, 30 bar, from PEM electrolysis,… 77 %; Carbon dioxide, captured at municipal solid waste incinerati… 18 %; Electricity, low voltage, at grid 2 %; Chemical plant, organics 1 %; Treatment, sewage, to wastewater treatment, class 1 1 %. Status: final control passed.
Item Value
Dataset name Methanol synthesis, hydrogen from electrolysis, CO2 from MSWI, with heat recovery (100:0 alloc.)
Dataset UUID / graph id 5048d7ff-2358-3cec-b3ea-0b82687eb3c9 / activity:methanol_synthesis_hydrogen_from_electrolysis_co2_from_mswi_with_heat_recovery_100_0_alloc__ch
Reference product, unit Methanol synthesis, hydrogen from electrolysis, CO2 from MSWI, with heat recovery (100:0 alloc.), 1 kg
Location CH
Time period 2024-01/2024-01
Category fuels / synthetic\transformation
Source database BAFU 2026 v1 (Swiss Federal Office for the Environment), version 2026 v1
Publisher Swiss Federal Office for the Environment (FOEN/BAFU)
Background database BAFU 2026 v1 (graph bafuquery-db)
LCIA method EF v3.1, consensus-flow-list implementation, 25 categories (bw2calc on the graph matrix)
Status final control passed
Documented by tdc-doc, imported mode (graph recalculation, Monte Carlo, final control), 2026-11-17

Introduction

Adapted from Comparative well-to-wheel life cycle assessment of OME3–5 synfuel production via the power-to-liquid pathway, Hank et al. 2019. CO2 and H2 inputs consolidated with Alternative production of methanol from industrial CO2. Meunier et al. 2020. Renewable Energy 146, pp. 1192-1203. Note that a 100:0 CO2 alloc. factor is applied: the carbon dioxide emissions are allocated to the MSWI plant, but the carbon capture efforts are within the system boundaries of the fuel producer. The combustion of the resulting methanol does not lead to carbon dioxide emissions. For more information, refer to Section I.C0.6 of Sacchi and Bauer, 2023. Source: Comparative well-to-wheel life cycle assessment of OME3–5 synfuel production via the power-to-liquid pathway. Christoph Hank, Lukas Lazar, Franz Mantei, Mohamed Ouda, Robin J. White, Tom Smolinka, Achim Schaadt, Christopher Hebling and Hans-Martin Henning. 2019. https://doi.org/10.1039/C9SE00658C UUID: 5048d7ff-2358-3cec-b3ea-0b82687eb3c9

This report documents an imported dataset: its inventory and metadata come from the publisher, not from the tdc pipeline. tdc-doc recomputes it on the graph, checks it (Section 7), and reports it in the ISO 14044 / BAFU DQR v2.1 structure used for tdc's own datasets. Sections that only apply to datasets built by tdc (stoichiometry, energy model, literature excerpts) are replaced by what the publisher declares.

Goal and scope

Function, functional unit and reference flow

Reference flow: 1 kg of Methanol synthesis, hydrogen from electrolysis, CO2 from MSWI, with heat recovery (100:0 alloc.) (CH). All results are given per unit of the reference flow.

System boundary

—

Technology

—

Native BAFU dataset: exchanges as delivered in EcoSpold v1, linked by the graph migration (graphlca.load).

LCIA method

EF v3.1, characterisation only (no normalisation or weighting), consensus-flow-list implementation of the 25 categories, with regionalised factors where the flow carries a place.

Life cycle inventory

Inventory table

Direct exchanges per reference flow, ordered by their share of climate change. Uncertainty: the distribution declared on the graph edge (BAFU: lognormal from the pedigree matrix). Pedigree: the scores the publisher declares (BAFU: reliability, completeness, temporal, geographical, technological, sample size; PEF DQR otherwise).

Exchange Type Location / compartment Amount Unit Uncertainty Pedigree GWP share (%) Notes
Hydrogen production, gaseous, 30 bar, from PEM electrolysis, from grid electrici… technosphere CH 0.192 kg lognormal, GSD² 1.38 — 76.9 ███████████████
Carbon dioxide, captured at municipal solid waste incineration plant, with heat … technosphere CH 1.446 kg lognormal, GSD² 1.38 — 17.6 ████
Electricity, low voltage, at grid technosphere CH 0.3029 kWh lognormal, GSD² 1.38 — 2.1 ·
Chemical plant, organics technosphere RER 2.0000e-10 p lognormal, GSD² 4.25 — 1.4 ·
Treatment, sewage, to wastewater treatment, class 1 technosphere CH 0.06882 m3 lognormal, GSD² 1.38 — 1.4 ·
Tap water, at user technosphere CH 68.82 kg lognormal, GSD² 1.38 — 0.7 ·
Reactors, distillation columns and heat exchangers for methanol production technosphere RER 7.4160e-10 p lognormal, GSD² 4.25 — 0.0 ·
Air compressor, screw-type compressor, 300 kW, at plant technosphere RER 1.6800e-08 p lognormal, GSD² 3.14 — 0.0 ·
Copper oxide, at plant technosphere RER 2.1140e-05 kg lognormal, GSD² 1.38 — 0.0 ·
Zinc oxide, at plant technosphere RER 7.9290e-06 kg lognormal, GSD² 1.38 — 0.0 ·
Aluminium oxide, at plant technosphere RER 3.9640e-06 kg lognormal, GSD² 1.38 — 0.0 ·
Transport, freight, lorry, 16t-32t gross weight, fleet average technosphere CH 1.6510e-06 tkm lognormal, GSD² 2.21 — 0.0 ·
Transport, freight, rail, electricity with shunting technosphere CH 1.8230e-05 tkm lognormal, GSD² 2.21 — 0.0 ·

Data quality

0 of 13 direct exchanges carry a declared pedigree, 13 carry a distribution.

Field As declared by the publisher
Data generator / entry / validation data generator: Romain Sacchi (PSI); data entry: Romain Sacchi (PSI); validation (proof reading): Romain Sacchi (PSI)
sampling procedure Sampling procedure: Literature data
validation details Proof reading validation: Passed, Other validation: none, Validator: Rolf Frischknecht, Telephone: 0041 44 940 61 91, E-mail: frischknecht@treeze.ch, Company: treeze, Country: CH

Data gaps, proxies and assumptions

None recorded.

Life cycle impact assessment (EF v3.1)

Per 1 kg. The 95 % interval and GSD² come from the Monte Carlo of Section 6.4.

Impact category Indicator Unit Result 2.5 % 97.5 % GSD²
Acidification Accumulated Exceedance (AE) mol H+ eq 0.003907 0.003018 0.008315 1.67
Climate change-Biogenic Radiative forcing as Global Warming Potential (GWP100) kg CO2 eq 0.03044 0.01941 0.05503 1.72
Climate change-Fossil Radiative forcing as Global Warming Potential (GWP100) kg CO2 eq 1.351 1.055 2.27 1.49
Climate change-Land use and land use change Radiative forcing as Global Warming Potential (GWP100) kg CO2 eq 0.003478 0.002028 0.006313 1.77
Climate change Radiative forcing as Global Warming Potential (GWP100) kg CO2 eq 1.385 1.076 2.33 1.49
EF-particulate Matter Impact on human health disease incidence 6.508e-08 4.978e-08 1.332e-07 1.63
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics Comparative Toxic Unit for ecosystems (CTUe) CTUe 8.687 7.6 16.82 1.5
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_organics Comparative Toxic Unit for ecosystems (CTUe) CTUe 0.06616 0.05634 0.213 2
Ecotoxicity, freshwater Comparative Toxic Unit for ecosystems (CTUe) CTUe 8.753 7.661 16.95 1.5
Eutrophication marine Fraction of nutrients reaching marine end compartment (N) kg N eq 0.002429 0.002006 0.003498 1.33
Eutrophication, freshwater Fraction of nutrients reaching freshwater end compartment (P) kg P eq 0.001193 6.759e-04 0.004933 2.8
Eutrophication, terrestrial Accumulated Exceedance (AE) mol N eq 0.01154 0.009893 0.01885 1.4
Human toxicity, cancer_inorganics Comparative Toxic Unit for human (CTUh) CTUh 3.743e-10 3.416e-10 1.132e-09 1.83
Human toxicity, cancer_organics Comparative Toxic Unit for human (CTUh) CTUh 5.206e-10 3.647e-10 9.815e-10 1.7
Human toxicity, cancer Comparative Toxic Unit for human (CTUh) CTUh 8.949e-10 7.624e-10 1.972e-09 1.63
Human toxicity, non-cancer_inorganics Comparative Toxic Unit for human (CTUh) CTUh 2.245e-08 2.034e-08 8.167e-08 2.04
Human toxicity, non-cancer_organics Comparative Toxic Unit for human (CTUh) CTUh 1.313e-09 7.879e-10 3.991e-09 2.28
Human toxicity, non-cancer Comparative Toxic Unit for human (CTUh) CTUh 2.376e-08 2.135e-08 8.427e-08 2.03
Ionising radiation, human health Human exposure efficiency relative to U235 kBq U235 eq 7.843 2.543 46.31 4.39
Land use Soil quality index pt (soil quality index) 18.25 11.69 36.73 1.78
Ozone depletion Ozone Depletion Potential (ODP) kg CFC-11 eq 1.388e-07 9.510e-08 2.528e-07 1.63
Photochemical ozone formation - human health Tropospheric ozone concentration increase kg NMVOC eq 0.002698 0.002223 0.005566 1.61
Resource use, fossils Abiotic resource depletion fossil fuels (ADP-fossil) MJ 80.4 55.07 141.6 1.63
Resource use, minerals and metals Abiotic resource depletion (ADP ultimate reserve) kg Sb eq 1.411e-05 8.280e-06 4.586e-05 2.36
Water use User deprivation potential (deprivation-weighted water consumption) m3 world eq deprived 0.7591 -2557 1248 —

Climate change 1.385 kg CO2 eq per kg. Main contributors: Hydrogen production, gaseous, 30 bar, from PEM electrolysis,… 77 %; Carbon dioxide, captured at municipal solid waste incinerati… 18 %; Electricity, low voltage, at grid 2 %; Chemical plant, organics 1 %; Treatment, sewage, to wastewater treatment, class 1 1 %.

Interpretation

Significant issues

Direct exchanges dominating climate change: Hydrogen production, gaseous, 30 bar, from PEM electrolysis,… 77 %; Carbon dioxide, captured at municipal solid waste incinerati… 18 %; Electricity, low voltage, at grid 2 %; Chemical plant, organics 1 %; Treatment, sewage, to wastewater treatment, class 1 1 %. Most sensitive exchanges (Section 6.3): Hydrogen production, gaseous, 30 bar, from PEM electrolysis, from grid electricity [CH] (-21.0 / +28.8 %); Carbon dioxide, captured at municipal solid waste incineration plant, with heat recovery, … (-4.8 / +6.6 %); Chemical plant, organics [RER] (-1.1 / +4.3 %).

Independent recalculation

Graph result against BAFU 2026 v1 published EF 3.1 results (LCIA Results.xlsx, June 2026):

Category Graph Published Graph / published
Acidification 0.003907 0.004882 0.800
Climate change-Biogenic 0.03044 0.03044 1.000
Climate change-Fossil 1.351 1.351 1.000
Climate change-Land use and land use change 0.003478 0.003478 1.000
Climate change 1.385 1.385 1.000
EF-particulate Matter 6.508e-08 6.508e-08 1.000
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics 8.687 8.938 0.972
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_organics 0.06616 0.06534 1.013
Ecotoxicity, freshwater 8.753 8.998 0.973
Eutrophication marine 0.002429 0.002425 1.001
Eutrophication, freshwater 0.001193 0.001193 1.000
Eutrophication, terrestrial 0.01154 0.01095 1.054
Human toxicity, cancer_inorganics 3.743e-10 3.600e-10 1.040
Human toxicity, cancer_organics 5.206e-10 5.206e-10 1.000
Human toxicity, cancer 8.949e-10 8.806e-10 1.016
Human toxicity, non-cancer_inorganics 2.245e-08 2.173e-08 1.033
Human toxicity, non-cancer_organics 1.313e-09 1.313e-09 1.000
Human toxicity, non-cancer 2.376e-08 2.304e-08 1.031
Ionising radiation, human health 7.843 7.842 1.000
Land use 18.25 14.47 1.261
Ozone depletion 1.388e-07 1.388e-07 1.000
Photochemical ozone formation - human health 0.002698 0.002698 1.000
Resource use, fossils 80.4 80.4 1.000
Resource use, minerals and metals 1.411e-05 1.384e-05 1.019
Water use 0.7591 1.548 0.490
Over all BAFU datasets, climate change agrees with the published table for 98.1 % of them within ±5 % (median ×1.000). Systematic differences are expected where the graph characterises differently from BAFU's table: regionalised factors (acidification, terrestrial eutrophication, land use, water use, by the flow's place) and the metal resource factors; these categories: Acidification median ×0.81 (16 % within ±5 %); Eutrophication, terrestrial median ×0.93 (37 % within ±5 %); Land use median ×1.23 (6 % within ±5 %); Resource use, minerals and metals median ×1.04 (52 % within ±5 %); Water use median ×0.75 (11 % within ±5 %). BAFU's table is per its own unit (electricity per MJ, cars per m, crops per m2), converted here, and carries the organics and inorganics sub-indicators of freshwater ecotoxicity in each other's column (primary copper: 99.7 % of its ecotoxicity under 'organics'); they are compared like with like.
Also published by BAFU for this dataset: IPCC 2021 GWP100 1.384 kg CO2 eq; Ecological Scarcity
2021 total 5819 UBP.

Sensitivity check

One at a time on each direct exchange, over its declared 95 % range (±50 % when none is declared, the tdc-doc default for an assumption without a range). The supply chain behind each input is held at its mean.

Exchange Base Low / high Range Δ GWP100 (%) Δ other categories (max %)
Hydrogen production, gaseous, 30 bar, from PEM electrolysis, from grid electricity [CH] 0.192 kg ×0.727 / ×1.38 lognormal, GSD² 1.38 -21.0 / +28.8 35.7 (Ionising radiation, human health)
Carbon dioxide, captured at municipal solid waste incineration plant, with heat recovery, … 1.446 kg ×0.727 / ×1.38 lognormal, GSD² 1.38 -4.8 / +6.6 14.8 (Eutrophication, terrestrial)
Chemical plant, organics [RER] 2.000e-10 p ×0.242 / ×4.13 lognormal, GSD² 4.25 -1.1 / +4.3 37.6 (Resource use, minerals and metals)
Electricity, low voltage, at grid [CH] 0.3029 kWh ×0.727 / ×1.38 lognormal, GSD² 1.38 -0.6 / +0.8 1.0 (Ionising radiation, human health)
Treatment, sewage, to wastewater treatment, class 1 [CH] 0.06882 m3 ×0.727 / ×1.38 lognormal, GSD² 1.38 -0.4 / +0.5 21.4 (Eutrophication marine)
Tap water, at user [CH] 68.82 kg ×0.727 / ×1.38 lognormal, GSD² 1.38 -0.2 / +0.2 2.6 (Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics)
Reactors, distillation columns and heat exchangers for methanol production [RER] 7.416e-10 p ×0.242 / ×4.13 lognormal, GSD² 4.25 -0.0 / +0.1 0.3 (Human toxicity, cancer_inorganics)
Air compressor, screw-type compressor, 300 kW, at plant [RER] 1.680e-08 p ×0.326 / ×3.07 lognormal, GSD² 3.14 -0.0 / +0.0 0.2 (Human toxicity, non-cancer_inorganics)
Copper oxide, at plant [RER] 2.114e-05 kg ×0.727 / ×1.38 lognormal, GSD² 1.38 -0.0 / +0.0 0.1 (Human toxicity, non-cancer_organics)
Zinc oxide, at plant [RER] 7.929e-06 kg ×0.727 / ×1.38 lognormal, GSD² 1.38 -0.0 / +0.0 0.0 (Ecotoxicity, freshwater_organics)
Aluminium oxide, at plant [RER] 3.964e-06 kg ×0.727 / ×1.38 lognormal, GSD² 1.38 -0.0 / +0.0 0.0 (Human toxicity, cancer_inorganics)
Transport, freight, lorry, 16t-32t gross weight, fleet average [CH] 1.651e-06 tkm ×0.46 / ×2.17 lognormal, GSD² 2.21 -0.0 / +0.0 0.0 (Ecotoxicity, freshwater_organics)
Transport, freight, rail, electricity with shunting [CH] 1.823e-05 tkm ×0.46 / ×2.17 lognormal, GSD² 2.21 -0.0 / +0.0 0.0 (Human toxicity, non-cancer_organics)

Uncertainty analysis

Monte Carlo over the whole supply chain: 1000 draws (seed 42, computed 2026-11-17), every exchange of the database that carries a distribution resampled at each draw, one adjoint solve per category per draw. Exchanges without a distribution enter as fixed values (Section 4.3). Results in Section 5.

Comparison with other data

No other location of this dataset in the graph.

Conclusions and limitations

GWP100 1.385 kg CO2 eq per kg (95 % interval 1.076–2.33). Dominant contributors: Hydrogen production, gaseous, 30 bar, from PEM electrolysis,… 77 %; Carbon dioxide, captured at municipal solid waste incinerati… 18 %; Electricity, low voltage, at grid 2 %; Chemical plant, organics 1 %; Treatment, sewage, to wastewater treatment, class 1 1 %. Most sensitive: Hydrogen production, gaseous, 30 bar, from PEM electrolysis, from grid electricity [CH] (-21.0 / +28.8 %); Carbon dioxide, captured at municipal solid waste incineration plant, with heat recovery, … (-4.8 / +6.6 %); Chemical plant, organics [RER] (-1.1 / +4.3 %). final control passed. The documentation relies on the publisher's metadata; this report is not a critical review in the sense of ISO 14044 clause 6.

Final control

Item Status Detail
reference flow PASS production amount 1.0 kg
closure: sum of direct contributions = dataset score (all 25 categories) PASS largest relative gap 3.5e-16
independent recalculation vs BAFU 2026 v1 published EF 3.1 results (LCIA Results.xlsx, June 2026) (climate change) PASS graph / published = 1; categories within ±5 %: 21/25
every technosphere input of the EcoSpold delivery is in the graph PASS all present (bafu_links_check.py)
uncertainty declared on the direct exchanges PASS 13/13 exchanges carry a distribution (100 %); the others enter the Monte Carlo as fixed values
Monte Carlo 95 % interval contains the deterministic score PASS 1.385 in [1.076, 2.33]
time period declared PASS 2024-01/2024-01
geography is a known location code PASS CH
sources cited PASS 2 reference(s), of which 1 dataset source(s); 0 resolved to a bibliographic record (DOI or Crossref/OpenAlex match), the others kept as the publisher declares them

References

  1. Report — source; as declared by BAFU (not found in OpenAlex/Crossref)
  2. Life Cycle Inventory database of the Swiss Federal Administration, BAFU:2026 — database; dataset citation
  3. International Organization for Standardization (2006). ISO 14044:2006 Environmental management — Life cycle assessment — Requirements and guidelines (incl. Amd 1:2017, Amd 2:2020). Geneva.
  4. Frischknecht R. (2023). FOEN LCI data — Data quality requirements (DQR) v2.1. treeze Ltd. on behalf of the Swiss Federal Office for the Environment (FOEN/BAFU), Uster / Bern. (tdc-doc method reference; title, version and year to verify against the user's copy)
  5. European Commission, Joint Research Centre (2022). Environmental Footprint (EF) reference package 3.1. Ispra.
  6. Mutel C. (2017). Brightway: An open source framework for Life Cycle Assessment. Journal of Open Source Software 2(12), 236. https://doi.org/10.21105/joss.00236

Annex — licence and terms of use

BAFU:2026 Terms of Use - free use, processing and reuse of the data (including in LCA studies and calculators); the data may not be sold, resold or distributed as a database; modifications must be documented and shared under equivalent terms; credit required.


To suggest a correction or a dataset that does not exist yet, use Propose a dataset.

datasets/bafu/5048d7ff-2358-3cec-b3ea-0b82687eb3c9.txt · Last modified: by 127.0.0.1

Donate Powered by PHP Valid HTML5 Valid CSS Driven by DokuWiki